The proposal for a disc golf course at Simmons Road Park was unanimously rejected following a tour of the property that was intended to sell the idea but instead backfired as people visualized how destructive the sport would be to the 24-acres of natural habitat and to neighbors.
"Let's have Simmons Road Park stay Simmons Road Park without any changes," said Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee Chairman Tom Camera, before calling the vote. The committee voted 6-0 to not consider any alterations to the park other then those already planned going forward.
Just two hours prior to the PRAC meeting, Tom Goad, president of 8 Flags Disc Golf Association, directed an on-site impact assessment of the project at Simmons Road Park. About 100 people braved sweltering heat and humidity along with the six members of the committee for the tour.
Leading people in groups averaging about 6 to 8 people, Goad guided them to a conceptual first hole that ran adjacent to a creek, with underbrush on both sides and houses located on the other side.
About half of those at Simmons Road Park then cooled off inside the City Commission Room for the PRAC meeting. Eighteen people, all opposing the disc golf plan, addressed the committee citing negative impacts on the 24-acres of property from what they had seen.
Numerous speakers cited disc golf players trampling through underbrush in search of errant disc throws. They pointed out the disruptive impact of having what Goad predicted would be "25 to 50" people a day near wetlands, natural habitat and noise generated by players to the adjacent neighborhoods. They pointed out the lack of parking at the location and concerns about who would be maintaining the disc golf course in the long term.
"This is a nonsensical idea," said Cameron Moss. "There must be something in the water because we've seen a racetrack proposed at the golf course. We've seen a solar farm proposed by clear cutting 36 acres of native forest. We've seen 11 85-foot towers proposed for the south end of the island. I'll take a business approach and say what's the demand (for this)."
The majority of speakers maintained that Simmons Road Park was intended to be a 'passive park" where visitors could enjoy the quiet comforts of nature and listen to the chorus of birds each day.
Committee member Phil Chapman said read the Parks and Recreation website that states "Preserving the community's natural environment."
"I don't think this (disc golf proposal) is keeping in line with that. I think this would be totally against it," he said.
The absence of any supporters at the meeting for the project re-enforced Chapman's opposition to disc golf at the Simmons Road Park location.
"If there is such a high demand for this disc golf course, not one person came and spoke in favor of it. Not one disc golfer came and said I'm in favor of this. This is a bad idea for this park," Chapman said.
Committee member Sheila Cocchi opposed the plan out of concern for people's safety in the natural environment, the lack of available parking and preserving habitat for birds and wildlife.
"I'd also like to point out that we are all county residents and there are no county funds in District 1 going to parks and recreation. Every dollar in the county for recreation is being spent west of District 1," Cocchi said. "I would encourage the disc golf people to explore opportunities with the county."
Cocchi said the city has been steadfast in stating that trees be protected. "This runs counter to that so I don't know how we can say one thing and then do something totally counter to that," she said.
The only changes to Simmons Road Park will be the installation of six educational signs informing visitors about the park's trees, wildlife and habitat.
We do not need the towers,the disc golf nor a Solar farm! Ideas SHOW THAT WE VOTED THE WRONG FOLKS IN OFFICE !!! Out to DESTROY OUR ISLAND ! NOW WITH US SPEAKING OUT AGAINST THEM THEY WILL LEARN.
As a retired ultimate Frisbee player and occasional disc golf player, I couldn't have been more against this proposal. Perhaps at a more open location on the island that does not mean the loss of so much habitat for wildlife. The build it and they will come mentality isn't doing the island any favors.
Doesn't the city commission get to vote on this also? If that is true, I would hesitate to celebrate too soon.
Great win!!
A perfect outcome for our perfect passive park! Thank you Mike for the coverage and thanks to everyone who showed up, stood up and spoke up to protect our gem that is Simmons Park! This is a perfect example of what we can accomplish if we don't give up.